Thursday, October 9, 2008

Yom Kippur

Walking around Manhattan today I was struck with a great feeling of exclusion and alienation... In this case, particulary from my own "Tribe"--Jews.
And, I hasten to add, its not that any one person or group is excluding me-- I have only myself to blame for this outsider state I'm in.
I have never been a religious Jew and I don't belong to any Synagogue or congregation. Yet, on these days, known to Jews as The High Holidays-- I feel an ache, a nostalgia and feeling of apartness more than any other time of the year.
Part of it is, I'm sure, that universal feeling one gets (no matter what group or religion or "tribe" you were born into) when certain holy or important times of the year come around. Its really family more than anything else.
If you're lucky, you still have your family and its still a close and basically caring situation... If you're not lucky, or you're merely older and people have died off or moved away, you are seized with a great longing for that warm feeling you once had...
Even in my Olympic-class dysfunctional family, I recall some religious celebrations and dinners, some organized (especially when my Grandmother was alive) attendance at the local Synagogue we belonged to.
I remember a warm, sunny October day, when we fasted all day long, didn't listen to the radio or ride in a car... The neighborhood was about half Jewish so there were people, dressed up and feeling the great signifigance of the holiday, walking on the street, greeting each other.
I guess part of this whole bittersweet experience for me is also the feeling of, not just family, but belonging to a coherent group of some sort--a group that shares beliefs and values and even a good deal of DNA...
And then, of course, there is always God... Religious or not, there is, for most people (and especially as mortality approaches) that incomprehensible but deep vibration in your soul-- some feeling that there is a greater and deeper connection-- Most of the time you are apart from it and, even if its not conscious, you feel the apartness. So, we have Yom Kippur-- The day of Atonement-- of At-one-ment; the day when you re-coonect with that great spirit or force or whatever you might want to call it.
As I walked around Manhattan today and saw families going to and from Synagogue, I was pulled again by deep old, nostalgic feelings...
With that preamble, I'm posting an essay I wrote about Yom Kippur four years ago on my website: http://www.federfiles.com....

Yom Kippur is here—The Day of Atonement for Jews who observe (and for most who don’t think they observe but really do). It is a day—and I’m always open to correction on subjects I know little about—when Jews reconcile themselves with their God.One tends to drift away from God during the course of a year—how could we not—being only poor defective human creations of an all-perfect being. Where does it say—in which part of the bible—that God made man “in his image.”? Well, if that’s the case, it seems like a pretty lousy deal for poor “man”—humankind. You get the form but not the substance. You get the resemblance to the father/mother/parent who created you, but not their strength, their will, and their infinite mercy—among other qualities.Well, anyway, we drift away from God and we are given, each year, this brief time to realize our departure from God, and attempt, by sacrifice, fasting, prayer and repentance to reunite—to Atone. Atonement being, in fact, At-one-ment—to be, once again, “at one” with God.
But speaking of Godlike qualities, the one that comes into play on Yom Kippur—more than the others—is infinite mercy. Because it is not just God with whom one has to reconcile themselves, it is also, one’s fellow creatures.
God is supposed to be infinitely forgiving; and, called upon with a sincere and repentant heart, will certainly forgive—whoever and whatever. The German poet Heine, when asked on his deathbed whether he should ask God forgiveness for his sins, is reputed to have said: “God will forgive, that’s his business.” Well that’s a little flip, and maybe Heine didn’t get forgiven, but you know what, I’m guessing he did… What parent, seeing the suffering of his child, no matter how unrepentant or disrespectful, would not forgive?
But much, much harder than securing the forgiveness and blessing of God the Father/Mother is securing the blessing and forgiveness of other people.We are not possessed of eternal wisdom and infinite mercy. We are, or can often be, petty, selfish and unforgiving (I know I am). We imagine that all our woes are caused by others. Indeed, some of us (and I know whereof I speak here) spend our lives demanding retribution for the crimes, real or perceived, that were committed against us.
On Yom Kippur, according to my source, a very well educated orthodox Rabbi, one goes about asking for forgiveness in the following manner: Truly repenting of the sin/crime you have committed against a fellow creature, you go to them and ask them to forgive you. If you are lucky and they are in a forgiving mood, you are forgiven (to what extent, only the forgiver knows in their heart). If they don’t forgive you, you go and ask again. If still turned away, you try one more time.If, after the third attempt at receiving forgiveness, you are spurned, then you have done all you can do and are free of the bond, of the debt (this is presuming its something intangible we are talking about here—but such things are generally, or can be, the worst and most enduring of crimes).
And, conversely, if someone comes to you and asks your forgiveness truly, you have three chances to unharden your heart and forgive them—and thus, you are free of your burden too—the burden of anger, hatred, vengeance, hurt pride.
It seems to me that I have carried both of these burdens—that I have been the unforgiving and the unforgiven for most of my life; in fact—right up until this very minute.Without going into great detail, I got a very raw deal from my parents when I was a kid—and even right up until the moment of both of their untimely deaths, I kept getting a raw deal.And one of the worst parts of this crummy deal was being told that I was the cause, the reason, for all the bad treatment I received as a child and young adult. I was given to understand, sometimes subtly, sometimes directly, that I was responsible for the mass of grief and suffering my parents had to go through. I still believe this.But, such an irrational situation is absurd. Part of me knows that I was essentially blameless for the sufferings of my parents. However, down deep, I really don’t understand this—and still feel—at bottom, an overwhelming sense of guilt about my parents. So I have both, a great sense—no matter how undeserved—of guilt and need to be forgiven, AND a deep, abiding and massive rage against such unfair treatment—including, of course, being made to feel guilty about my alleged crimes.
I have—to the absolute detriment of every other part of my life—nourished and cherished this hatred, vengeance and unforgiving implacability against my parents for almost sixty years—just as I have carried the false guilt all this time.
In fact, I have two burdens to carry—and to try to set down—this Yom Kippur (and every other day in the calendar): How do I forgive myself and how do I forgive my parents—after all this time? Because, though it seems a sort of self-help truism by now, I know in my heart that if I don’t set these burdens down, life will just be a pale imitation of what it could really be.So, that’s my question for myself, and, perhaps, if it seems familiar, to you, on this day of atonement. You can reconcile yourself with God, and you can try to reconcile yourself with other people, but how do you reconcile yourself with and to yourself?Because, to live, to actually exist and have life mean anything, you must forgive yourself and you must forgive others. Vengeance, hatred, rage, the enduring hurt of unjust behavior… is a fire that keeps re-igniting itself until it consumes you.The only real things remaining are sadness and forgiveness. Sadness and forgiveness— And we pray for them to come into our hearts.

4 comments:

Barry said...

Mike
I, like you, am not observant but there is a bond to my youth, to my life as a whole, that vibrates, if you will, on Yom Kippur. I was always referred to, our family referred to ourselves, as 'conservative' Jews. When I moved to Long Island, we sought out a synagogue to have some type, albeit, infrequent, connection to a Jewish community. My son considered Hebrew School torture, so we were connected to a Reform Temple. After one Friday nite, called Family Night, where the Shabbos service is held but then the Rabbi calls people up and the congregation tells and hears stories, we left drained. It was 90 minutes or so, and this feeble attempt brought us to a conclusion that allows me to paraphrase Woody Allen......."we thought we were Conservative, but no, much less observant than that.....Reform....very Reform, ultra Reform.................Nazi"

It was here that I realized on a visceral level that group religion was anathema for me, be it my own, of which I'm fairly proud, or any other. Religion to me, is me, and God. It's Mike Feder and God. It's Woody Allen and God.

I had lost my brother, my one sibling, 11 years ago, and many responsibilities in my family fell on my shoulders, esp. the care of our parents. My brother was a physician, so I planned these years as having my brother take care of all medical decisions, and I would do everything else; visit for the holidays, visit any day, call, have over for dinner, and so on. Going thru multiple crisis with my parents' health, my wife having breast cancer, a nephew with cancer, I found myself speaking to my brother in the car en route to work. It occurred to me that if I gave any creedence to his listening to me, why would I avoid trying to speak with God. Long story/short (well, it's a bit too late for that), I find myself speaking to God, and it's in prayer, it's in anger, it's in simple narrative. So, surprisingly, I find myself more 'religious', and even speaking of upcoming events, I say 'God willing', and in speaking of past and present, "thank God". ..Barry, how are your parents?... "Thank God, Dad is ......and mom is...."

When I start my own blog (looks like I just did, sorry) I'd need to get into how the passage of time, and hitting 50 six years ago, has affected me, in this regard, and others. But I do know that my family dressed up on Yom Kippur, and we went to Temple, and we didn't eat, and we were with family, and now........a lot of that is gone, and it makes me sad. I'm leaving shortly to have the traditional dinner after the fast with my 86 y.o. dad, mom 83, mom in law 87, and my wife's 2nd cousin, 88.
I'm unclear on many things, but I do know that tonight,in the 50 yard dash, I come out winning. (I think.)

a healthy, and safe, year to one and all.
Barry

1-Observer said...

Mike, I am deeply moved by your post. I came to your blog today because I heard you mention on the radio that the trauma of your childhood has hit you harder all these years later. I, too, have carried rage and sorrow for the cruelty and neglect I experienced as a child. By my mid-fifties, I thought I had pushed past it all. But the constant trauma of my developmental years blindsided me with debilitating cognitive and hormonal disorders--and a fresh round of rage and sorrow for things I could not control, either then or now.

Just two months ago, my mother--the mother who abused and abandoned me--died a difficult death. I sat with her for the last thirty-six hours. She was afraid. As I held her hand and cried with her, I felt broken by the great pain she brought into her life and mine, just as her own mother had caused her so much pain. As the hours passed, I went on a strange journey through pain and grief and, finally, into my own Day of Atonement. Shortly before she passed, I forgave her. And I knew without a doubt that if I could forgive her, the Spirit most certainly would forgive her--and the rest of us who are just doing our level best in a very tough world.

Thank you so much for sharing some of your own journey. Blessings.

Barry said...

My experience has not been as severe as described by Mike and Observer. I'd post a few details, but I've learned the internet 'google' search of our names would bring up even small blog comments.
A family therapist with whom I've worked, for 10 years now, helping me thru deaths, life situations, separations, illnesses of family, etc, had an extraordinary few of parents. Notwithstanding abusive parents, altho we know there is out and out abuse, and there is a subtle exercise of consistently poor parenting that has an abusive quality to it, he feels it is an obligation to ourselves to work out the most severe, and the less severe, issues. ESPECIALLY if the parent(s) remain alive. He suggests taking into account, as hard as it is, the things the parent(s) did, providing food, clothes, everything and everything, minor or major. And that in whatever way you can allow for the failings of the parent, it will benefit not only your feelings about your life with them, but with your primary relationships now, spouse/partner/children/friend/co workers.

In a nut shell, I can tell you I know that my father's issues were markedly affected by his younger siblings both having polio, this is nearly 70 years ago, and they both lived with his after effects. My father, the oldest and the ONE who did not get the disease, was sent away from the family; the family was quarantined, but I think my father saw illness as a means of maintaining and getting love. I have worked hard to understand this, and while I still get very angry, VERY angry, I understand why he acts the way he does, and it helps. It doesn't excuse, but it explains.
My mother's mother had a paralyzing stroke when my mother was 4, and then died when she was 10. My mother became a housekeeper to two critical men, her dad and older brother. She has been a housewife, and that is all, for 65 years.
Again, things I have had to deal with were made 'easier' when I allow for what she went through. Explanation, not to be excused.
But explanations sometimes help in forgiving, and forgiving, it is my feeling, is not yes or no. You can forgive 50% or 100% or 33%.......
I inherited, or lived with, some very severe situations (my brother died 11 years ago) and brought to the parenting of my son issues that he may need to understand as he grows past his current 19. I want to help him with this, so I've been trying to explain, to apologize, to tell him "I'm wrong", to assert what I think is right, even if he gets angry about it, from his birth up till now. I think many of us were told anger was not good, I was. I think many of us have to take the demon out of being angry. It can be edifying, it certainly is often justified, and it can allow closure over a problem, and if accepted (being angry and accepting anger are two tough nuts), life can move on.......as it should.
I hope he cuts me some slack. And I plan to work on it till there is no more breath.

Tom said...

Right on Brother ....'If someone comes to you and asks your forgiveness truly, you have three chances to unharden your heart and forgive them—and thus, you are free of your burden too—the burden of anger, hatred, vengeance, hurt pride.'
It is really that easy! ... if you forgive you are forgiven...if you give you get...if you plant corn you get corn...